Clinical research, 2005

Hypnosis and cancer

In 2005 in Perth, Western Australia, Rick Collingwood and pharmacist Nathan Elliott ran a clinical trial measuring what specialised mind body hypnosis did to the quality of life of cancer patients. Nine patients took part. Eight completed all six sessions. The full report is below, unedited.

Participants
Nine, four male and five female
Sessions
Six each, one hypnotherapist
Instrument
EORTC QLQ-C30 core questionnaire
Analysis
Paired t-test
What this trial did not test

The trial measured quality of life. It did not test whether hypnosis treats or cures cancer, and it makes no such claim. Rick Collingwood's own position, in his words from the report: asked whether hypnosis can cure cancer, his answer is definitely not.

Every participant obtained a referral from their treating doctor and stayed on their conventional medical treatment throughout. Anyone diagnosed with cancer should listen first to their oncologist and medical doctor.

A word from Rick

I have spent more than twenty years in full time practice as a clinical hypnotherapist and I have been training hypnosis since 1996. During that time I have helped thousands of individuals afflicted with a vast array of physical and emotional challenges. Most have been able to move beyond their restricting belief systems and gain some benefit, but there are always a few exceptions.

There is endless speculation from all quarters regarding the causes of and cures for cancer, and there are even more therapies available to the afflicted, but there is no panacea or magic bullet. While billions of dollars are spent every year on research, cancer itself continues to spread throughout the world, striking randomly and leaving too much physical, mental, emotional and financial destruction in its wake.

There is a school of thought that all sickness, and cancer especially, results from emotional imbalances. In my opinion there must be an emotional and stress component to many diseases, but to state that all cancer is caused by an emotional conflict is foolish and incorrect, because many of the emotional associations to a disease take hold after a conscious awareness of it. Cancer is caused by many reasons and they are as different and individual as the many types of disease called cancer. The fundamental cause is largely unknown, but the reasons include environmental, genetic and emotional factors to varying degrees, or a combination of all three.

For most cancers the fact remains that there is no cure, and I would advise all seekers to steer a wide berth around any person who claims that all cancer is caused by the mind, or that they can cure cancer, if those claims cannot be backed up with valid and verifiable scientific evidence. I would also advise any person diagnosed with cancer to listen firstly to their oncologist and medical doctor. Common sense dictates that a healthy attitude, fresh food, clean water, some daily sunshine, exercise and good sleep is an idealistic pattern for all, whether presently healthy or not.

There are many derivatives of hypnosis facading behind snappy names and acronyms, which sometimes purport remarkable or instant remedies for all manner of ills. I propose that apparently miraculous cures often miraculously reverse into the non-permanence of wishful thinking. Just because an individual who has been sick may feel better, it does not mean that they are in fact well.

Why I undertook the trial

Firstly, I was having successes using hypnosis to alleviate the crippling effects in sufferers of chronic fatigue syndrome and non-insulin dependent diabetes. Then I did experimental work with Parkinson's disease which yielded significant results in the amelioration of symptoms. I stress that I insist any sick person I work with must remain under their doctor's care and stay on their prescribed medications.

The final reason was the numerous testimonials arriving in my inbox from people all over Australia reporting significant benefits from regular use of my Mind-Body Healing Program. All of the participants in the clinical study were required to use the program daily as an adjunct to their weekly in-person hypnosis sessions for the entire duration of the protocol.

Beyond my years as a therapist, I learned a lot from this study. I learned about excruciating physical and emotional pain. I learned about hope. I learned about fear. I learned about faith and the strength of the human spirit. But mostly I learned about respect. Not only for the sufferers who took part, but for every victim of cancer and their families, and for those people from all of the caring professions who work tirelessly to bring healing and comfort to the sufferers of cancer.

In my opinion this study has been a success beyond my expectations, and I believe beyond the expectations of the participants. I would like to thank them all, and to thank my colleague Nathan Elliott, a pharmacist also endowed with the knowledge and skills of hypnosis. Without Nathan's academic and professional expertise this trial would not have been possible. This was our trial, not mine alone. Thanks also to the medical doctors and oncologists who had the open-mindedness to approve their patients into the trial.

I do not believe that anything can cure most cancers, but I do believe that cancer is sometimes created from within, and that once a sufferer has a conscious awareness of the diagnosis then the mind plays a significant part in the experience and the outcome of the treatment.

Because there are now so many modalities that profess to be hypnosis but are actually only aspects of it, I strongly discourage any person from using hypnosis for curative purposes without first consulting their medical doctor. Also ensure that the hypnotherapist has adequate knowledge and training in the use of hypnosis, and experience with the specialist techniques required to work with pain management.

This trial and all my cancer work was and is undertaken using traditional hypnosis, not snappy named hybrids. It is far more involved than just relaxing someone and having them imagine an army of good soldiers hunting down cancer cells. It took me five years of experimental work to formulate the correct procedures and terminologies to get the results presented here.

The clinical report

Collingwood BR, Elliott NJ

Hypnosis as an allied therapy to improve the quality of life of cancer patients

Australian Academy of Hypnosis and Advanced Mind Dynamics Pty Ltd, Perth, Australia

Abstract

Complementary and alternative medicine used by cancer patients is becoming much more prevalent the world over. Many beneficial outcomes have been seen from the addition of hypnosis to conventional protocols. As with all treatments, the focus of the hypnotherapy is to ameliorate the effects of pain and to restore a level of psychological and physical wellbeing and functioning. The EORTC QLQ-C30 core questionnaire was used to assess changes in perceived quality of life. Each patient received six hypnotherapy sessions, conducted by the same hypnotherapist each time, and questionnaires were completed prior to induction of trance.

Responses were evaluated comparing the initial questionnaire with the final questionnaire. Statistically significant improvements were noted with fatigue, global health status, insomnia and physical functioning. All aspects of the questionnaire showed improvement following the six sessions. Overall, patients experienced the benefit of hypnosis in reducing symptoms and increasing their overall quality of life. Many commented that commencing hypnosis at the time of diagnosis, and continuing throughout their treatment, would have been greatly beneficial.

Background

Complementary and alternative medicine used by cancer patients is becoming much more prevalent around the world. Patients with all tumour types and stages use it in the hope of cure, disease control, longer survival, improved quality of life and palliation. Most is used in addition to current conventional medical treatment, therefore it does not reduce health costs, and disclosure to physicians is usually incomplete. Breast cancer patients who use it tend to have higher levels of psychosocial distress.

Introduction

During the period surrounding a diagnosis of cancer, people can experience anxiety, emotional and physical distress and mood disturbance. During treatment these symptoms are often compounded by side-effects including nausea, vomiting, and procedural and disease related physical pain. Conventional medicine targets pain, distress and depression, however conventional treatments do not always relieve these symptoms to patient satisfaction. Often these patients will opt for complementary and alternative medicine such as acupuncture, naturopathy, homoeopathy and mind-body techniques in an attempt to reduce symptoms, and even in the hope of a cure.

The National Institutes of Health define mind-body therapies as interventions that use a variety of techniques designed to facilitate the mind's capacity to affect bodily functions and symptoms. Many hospitals are seeing the benefit of these therapies in conjunction with current treatments and establishing mind-body cancer research programs. Hypnosis has been used to reduce side-effects and allow patients to function better emotionally and physically, and many literature reviews describe beneficial outcomes from its addition to conventional protocols.

Quality of life in cancer patients is one common measure for treatment success, particularly in palliation. Symptoms relating to psychological distress and existential concerns are even more prevalent than pain and other physical symptoms among those with life-limiting conditions. Specific non-Ericksonian hypnosis techniques were used in the study that follows.

Patients and methods

The study was conducted on nine patients, four male and five female, with various cancers: one prostate, two bowel, three breast and two oesophageal. To participate, patients obtained a referral from their treating doctor and were required to remain on current conventional medical treatment unless modified by that doctor. The EORTC QLQ-C30 core questionnaire was used to assess changes in perceived quality of life, completed at the initial interview and then prior to each hypnosis session. All patients completed the questionnaires unassisted and all questions were answered. Patients were also given a hypnosis recording to listen to once a day for the course of the study. Each patient received six hypnotherapy sessions with the same hypnotherapist. Statistical analysis was performed using paired t-test analysis.

Of the nine patients commencing the study, eight completed all six sessions. One female patient withdrew after four sessions due to weakness following intensive radiotherapy. The average age of male patients was 63 years, range 50 to 76. The average age of female patients was 56 years, range 47 to 64. All patients completing the study maintained regular contact with their doctor.

Clinical results

Functional scales improve as the number rises. Symptom scales improve as the number falls. Every scale moved in the direction of improvement.

Measure
Initial
Session six
p value
Fatigue (fa)
Statistically significant
35.75%
12.38%
p<0.0044
Global health status / QOL (ql)
Statistically significant
63.50%
79.00%
p<0.0058
Insomnia (sl)
Statistically significant
53.75%
8.25%
p<0.008
Physical functioning (pf)
Statistically significant
75.75%
87.25%
p<0.0395
Nausea and vomiting (nv)
Moderate significance
20.88%
0.00%
p<0.095
Constipation (co)
Moderate significance
20.63%
4.13%
p<0.1036
Cognitive functioning (cf)
Moderate significance
68.75%
85.50%
p<0.138
Emotional functioning (ef)
Improved
66.88%
82.25%
p<0.125
Pain (pa)
Improved
26.88%
14.63%
p<0.171
Diarrhoea (di)
Improved
12.38%
4.13%
p<0.171
Role functioning (rf)
Improved
29.13%
54.25%
p<0.351
Dyspnoea (dy)
Improved
8.25%
4.13%
p<0.351
Figure 2
Insomnia
0%25%50%75%100%13%75%Not at all25%25%A little bit50%Quite a bit13%Very muchInitial, mean 53.75Session six, mean 8.25

Patients rated their lack of sleep over the previous week on a four-point scale. Three quarters reported no insomnia at all by the sixth session.

Figure 3
Nausea and vomiting
0%25%50%75%100%50%100%025%173313%506713%83100Initial, mean 20.88Session six, mean 0.00

Scored 0 to 100. Every patient scored zero at the sixth session, and the group reduced its as-required anti-nausea medication over the same period.

Figure 4
Fatigue
0%25%50%75%100%25%013%38%1113%38%2250%334413%5513%667788100Initial, mean 35.75Session six, mean 12.38

Scored 0 to 100. Fatigue showed the largest statistical response of any measure in the trial.

Discussion

Insomnia

Insomnia is a prevalent form of sleep difficulty which reduces quality of life, decreases work potential and increases health care utilisation. One of the most statistically significant improvements in the analysis was in insomnia. The patients' initial responses were slightly higher than those suggested for the general population, which would be expected as disease and mood factors influence insomnia. The response to hypnosis was rapid, with most patients reporting dramatic improvement within the first three sessions, and that improvement was then maintained for the remainder of the study. Emotional functioning issues like irritability, tension, anxiety and depression all decreased over the same period, which may have added to it.

Gastrointestinal symptoms

Many symptoms patients experience during cancer treatment are related either to their medication or directly to the cancer. Gastrointestinal symptoms like diarrhoea and constipation can lead to nausea and appetite loss. Throughout the study period the participants showed increased appetite and reduced nausea and vomiting. One patient was amazed by the return of normal taste sensation instead of a metallic taste, and another began to put on weight while undergoing chemotherapy and radiotherapy. Over the study period patients reduced their as-required anti-nausea medication, which indicates the reduction was not merely in their perception of the symptom or an increased effect of current medication.

Physical functioning

Physical functioning covers the ability to take a long or short walk, the need to spend time in bed or a chair, the ability to carry out daily activities and the ability to perform strenuous activity. During the study there were changes in patients' perception of daily activities. Initially many described a long walk as a distance of one kilometre. At the conclusion of the study many perceived a long walk to be four kilometres or more. The increase in energy described by patients, and the change in their perception of a long walk, may indicate direct effects on the body's energy levels from the hypnosis, not just an increase in sleep reducing fatigue.

Fatigue

Fatigue is one of the most common symptoms experienced by cancer patients and is associated with significant impairment in functioning and overall quality of life. It showed the greatest response statistically, with all patients describing increased energy levels, decreased time spent at rest and a greater ability to live their lives the way they wish.

Global health status

Global health status represents a patient's feeling as to their overall wellbeing, based upon that individual's beliefs and experiences. During the study some participants' global health status measure dipped dramatically after the second session, even with improvements in all other aspects of their questionnaire. When questioned about this decline, they stated that they had previously been comparing their quality of life with when they were sick, and now compared it to how they felt before they had any symptoms. All patients in their subsequent questionnaires then showed improved global health status, which indicates the change in outlook of participants to their quality of life.

Conclusions

The hypnotic techniques used in this study demonstrated significant improvements in all aspects of the patients' quality of life. Patients had more energy, were more active after hypnosis and were more able to cope with the difficulties they face in their everyday lives. A clinically significant improvement was seen with insomnia, nausea, physical functioning and global health status.

Hypnosis can affect perception of symptoms, however in this study the results seemed to point to a deeper change, with energy and fatigue being modified positively. The experience of hypnosis was described as beneficial by all patients. Patients commented that they would have seen the best benefit if hypnosis was begun around the time of diagnosis and continued throughout their treatment.

In this study, hypnosis has been beneficial for symptom control and for increasing the quality of life in patients with cancer. Further research into the use of specific non-Ericksonian hypnosis techniques for symptom control and improved quality of life, involving a larger number of participants, is needed to support these results.

The nine participants

Each participant kept a verbal record at every session. The reports are reproduced as they were taken. Participants are unnamed in the original.

01

71 year old male

Diagnosis
Prostate cancer with bone secondaries, 1994

Medical care
Radiotherapy, Androcur and Zoladex. Current medications Zocor and Losec.

Presenting issues
Insomnia, Loss of appetite, Physical aches and pains, Constipation, Fear

5 May 2005
  • Hip pain that had been predominant for three years disappeared the first night on the Mind-Body recording and did not return.
  • Usual tiredness about the same.
  • Bowel motions improved a little, after three years of constipation.
12 May 2005
  • Hip pain still gone. Pain in both wrists, also three years old, much less for long periods.
  • Sleeping much better with the recording.
  • Bowel motions remained a little better.
  • Fell and sprained an ankle. Medical investigation reported a sprain only, and walking required a cane.
19 May 2005
  • Wrist pain improving gradually. Right wrist more painful, especially in the morning. Left wrist pain free.
  • Hips still pain free.
  • Ankle feeling much better.
  • The recording is assisting deep sleep.
  • Generally feeling fantastic.
31 May 2005
  • Ankle pain gone, no further use for the cane.
  • All elimination systems working much better, previous constipation gone.
  • Sleeping deeper and for longer, waking refreshed.
  • After the session on 19 May, walked up and down one hundred steps with no difficulty or discomfort.
  • Both wrists pain free.
9 June 2005
  • Sleeping like a log every night.
  • No pain or discomfort anywhere in the body.
  • Elimination systems fine.
  • Physical energy improved considerably.
  • Motivation improved significantly.
  • Generally feels much better and much happier.
16 June 2005
  • Sleep still much improved.
  • Energy and motivation still improved.
  • Hip pain gone since the first session and never returned.
  • Very mild pain in the left wrist, left ankle and both knees, worse on stairs.
Final assessment, 16 June 2005
I think this has been very worthwhile indeed, and there have definitely been significant improvements in my sleeping, much much less pain, and much more energy. Generally, I just feel much better. I must admit that at the beginning I was a sceptic, now I am convinced there is something very valid in all of this.
02

64 year old female

Diagnosis
Dukes C rectal cancer, February 2004

Medical care
Operated on March 2004, then chemotherapy and radiotherapy. Current treatment Thyroxin, not associated with the cancer.

Presenting issues
Stress, Anger, Insomnia, Depression, Anxiety, Constipation

3 May 2005
  • Feeling generally well.
  • Gets a little tired if doing too much.
  • Sleeping much better and deeper since using the Mind-Body recording.
  • Went away and forgot the recording, and still slept much better than usual.
  • Generally feeling happier and lighter within herself.
5 May 2005
  • Feeling pretty good since the first session.
  • Still sleeping better.
  • Less bothered by her husband's snoring, and can go back to sleep after waking in the night. Previously she would lie awake worrying about the future.
10 May 2005
  • Sleep still much improved.
  • Appetite improving.
  • Energy levels up quite a bit.
  • Stressing and worrying has stopped.
  • Feeling much happier.
12 May 2005
  • Elimination systems functioning much better, after frequent constipation or diarrhoea since the operation.
  • Sleep still fine.
  • Appetite still improving.
  • Energy still up.
  • States she feels better than she has felt for years.
17 May 2005
  • As at 12 May, and more relaxed and calm, less reactive, less worried and concerned.
19 May 2005
  • As at 17 May.
Final assessment, 1 June 2005
Mood wise I am definitely much better. I feel much more positive in general. I am sleeping much better and deeper. My energy has been steadily improving. Asked to rate the benefit from one to ten, she reported eight to ten. Asked if she would do it again, she said that because of the improvements she felt from the first day, she would have begun the hypnosis treatments immediately she was diagnosed had she known about them at the time.
03

47 year old female

Diagnosis
Advanced breast cancer, 10 March 2000, with secondaries in the liver, lungs, ovaries and bones

Medical care
Chemotherapy, radiotherapy, hormone therapy. Current treatment chemotherapy Navelbine and Bonefos. Began two weeks before the other participants and received four extra sessions.

Presenting issues
Fear, Pain, Loss of appetite, Insomnia, Weight loss, Low energy

29 March 2005
  • Initial interview, then twenty seven minutes of deep hypnosis with positive reinforcing suggestions regarding her state of health, the ability of her body to heal, and her mood remaining calm, happy and confident.
7 April 2005
  • Went for chemotherapy and was nowhere near as worried as usual.
  • Felt a little pre-injection anxiety, then relaxed completely as the cannula went in. In her own words, it was as though the arm was hypnotised.
  • Much better after chemotherapy: no nausea, no mouth ulcers, no headache, no constipation.
  • Constant pain in the right leg reduced by at least half.
  • Still reporting insomnia.
  • Emotionally feeling a little better.
14 April 2005
  • Sore arm from the second chemotherapy on 11 April.
  • No nausea from the chemotherapy.
  • Felt dizzy on Wednesday 13 April.
  • Constipation easing.
  • Appetite improved a lot.
  • Liver function tests show improvement.
  • Sleeping still not good.
21 April 2005
  • Sleeping better and able to get back to sleep more easily.
  • Feeling more emotionally stable.
  • No constipation or diarrhoea after chemotherapy.
  • Energy levels still improving.
  • Skin colour less yellow and blotchy.
  • Past hip and leg pains gone.
  • Appetite has returned.
3 May 2005
  • Chemotherapy again on 2 May with no nausea, no constipation or diarrhoea and no mouth ulcers. The oncologists appeared surprised with her progress.
  • Moving a lot better and physically more mobile.
  • Right leg pain down forty per cent, left leg dull ache gone.
  • General mood a lot happier.
10 May 2005
  • Feeling better each week.
  • More mobile and comfortable walking.
  • Sleeping a lot longer and deeper.
  • Feeling more emotionally balanced.
  • Appetite now really good.
17 May 2005
  • Last radiotherapy on the afternoon of 10 May, with a mild headache that evening.
  • Began chemotherapy again on 11 May with no pain, no nausea and no mouth ulcers.
  • Energy levels very much up.
  • Still sleeping deeper and longer.
  • Much less worried.
  • Appetite still very good.
31 May 2005
  • No nausea, no pain, no ulceration.
  • Sleeping deeply and for longer.
  • Gained a kilogram in weight.
  • Energy levels still fine.
  • Reports feeling a little fluey.
7 June 2005
  • Appetite still better.
  • Energy levels still up.
  • Pain still gone.
  • Sleeping still fine.
  • Still feels a little fluey.
14 June 2005
  • Had the flu for the past week.
  • Feeling well, and better than would be expected.
  • Appetite down, some constipation, felt a little dizzy.
  • Still sleeping very well.
  • Pain in a muscle under the right arm from vacuuming and hanging out washing. She laughs and says: a month ago I couldn't even do the washing or vacuuming.
04

64 year old female

Diagnosis
Breast cancer, 1984

Medical care
Lumpectomy 1984, full mastectomy of the right breast 1997. Medications Aromasin, Warfarin, Methadone and Hydromorphine.

Presenting issues
Pain in the back, Loss of appetite, Loss of energy, Fear

3 May 2005
  • Appeared weak and ravaged by the cancer and by treatment side effects.
  • Reported severe pain in the back muscles and spine.
  • Reported very low appetite.
10 May 2005
  • No pain all week.
  • Better sleep.
  • Could not stand the smell of food as it made her nauseous.
  • Appeared much happier both physically and emotionally.
  • Concerned about being given six doses of radiotherapy at once on 11 May.
17 May 2005
  • Appetite returned and consistent all week.
  • Gained two kilograms in weight.
  • No pain all week.
  • Sleeping well.
31 May 2005
  • Arrived with a morphine pump attached, with nausea and vomiting and complete loss of appetite.
  • Severe lower back pain.
  • Told by her doctor between 18 and 30 May that she has two months to live without more chemotherapy, and possibly six months with it.
  • The pharmacist checked the contents of the pump and found a possible medication conflict.
  • Too weak and incoherent for hypnosis.

Her husband rang to withdraw her from the trial, saying she was too weak and would begin another course of chemotherapy. Hers is the one incomplete record of the nine.

05

50 year old male

Diagnosis
Rectal adenocarcinoma, March 2004

Medical care
Pre-operative chemotherapy then rectal resection surgery, and a temporary stoma bag still required because of a non-healing abscess.

Presenting issues
Anger, Burning pains, Insomnia, Depression, Energy loss, Constant worry

3 May 2005
  • The recording helps him sleep much better and deeper.
  • Reports a great deal of stress in the home environment and in a family relationship.
  • Reports the domestic situation and the stoma bag make him constantly angry.
  • Reports total sexual dysfunction.
12 May 2005
  • Called in the morning reporting havoc at home and cancelled the appointment, rescheduling for 19 May.
19 May 2005
  • Home environment still causing much stress.
  • Disgust at the stoma bag and having to wear it.
  • Still sleeping deeper and can go back to sleep after waking.
  • Raw skin around the stoma entrance and local pain from eating acidic foods.
7 June 2005
  • Feels more tolerant towards his partner and the domestic situation.
  • Feels the treatment is helping significantly with anger and he is now much calmer.
  • Sleeping deeply. Abscess weeping beginning to slow.
  • Has more energy.
9 June 2005
  • Feels more emotionally stable and less reactive.
  • Sleeping fine now.
  • Burning pain around the stoma entrance gone.
  • Has more physical energy.
14 June 2005
  • Discharge from the abscess has slowed to almost nothing.
  • Feels much more positive.
  • Still sleeping deeply.
  • Energy levels up.
  • Feels more tolerance and less anger towards other people.
16 June 2005
  • Feels the same as on 14 June, although the infection seems to have dried up.
Final assessment, 6 June 2005
Feels as though the abscess infection has slowed considerably after leaking like a tap for six months. All of my results are positive. I sleep much deeper and better. My anger is much less. Still slightly depressed about my domestic and relationship situation. Stopped going off at the kids all the time, and calmly remove myself from stressful situations. Feels much more tolerant, and has much more energy and a much more positive attitude.
06

64 year old female

Diagnosis
Cancer of the left breast, March 2004, and thyroid cancer, October 2004

Medical care
Full left breast mastectomy. Medications Arimidex and Felodipine. Had one fifteen minute hypnosis session at a Cancer Council of WA meeting in Mandurah on 19 April 2005.

Presenting issues
Insomnia, Itching skin, Mild obsessive compulsive behaviour, Loss of appetite

May 2005
  • The recording is helping her sleep much better.
  • Aches in the right arm.
  • Previous leg cramps still gone.
  • Eighteen months of itching arms, a medication side effect, went after the first treatment and has not returned.
  • Arthritis feels much less painful.
  • Bowel and elimination systems working better.
10 May 2005
  • Feeling much more relaxed and much less pedantic around the home, especially concerning a slight obsessive compulsion about house cleanliness.
  • Feeling very good generally.
  • Feeling much less worried.
  • Two nights of disturbed sleep.
17 May 2005
  • Sleeping deeply and soundly again.
  • Arm itching still gone.
  • A generally much more relaxed disposition.
  • Feeling much more comfortable.
  • More energy in general.
31 May 2005
  • Feeling great.
  • Energy has lifted so much that she had been up on the roof trimming overhanging palm trees.
  • Sleeping deeply still.
  • Aching lumps either side of the front of the neck, diagnosed as a result of the strenuous activity.
  • Asks whether a three kilometre daily walk is too much.
  • Much happier and more relaxed around the home.
7 June 2005
  • Feeling on top of the world.
  • Neck lumps gone by the evening of 31 May.
  • General memory appears to be getting much better.
  • Energy levels still way up.
  • Going back to sleep after waking in the night is automatic now.
14 June 2005
  • Slept like a log all week.
  • Daily walk now increased to four kilometres.
  • Feels as though all previous negativity has been vacuumed out of her brain.
  • Feeling great.
Final assessment, 14 June 2005
It has been fantastic. I didn't know that things could be so affected by the depth within the mind. My energy is much better, everything about my body works much better, I'm more relaxed, I eat better, and I've learned not to bother worrying. This has been the best thing.
07

58 year old male

Diagnosis
Cancer of the oesophagus, 20 January 2005

Medical care
FEC chemotherapy. A returned serviceman who served with the Australian Special Air Service in Vietnam and was diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder after returning in 1973. Other non-medical treatments included vitamin C injections.

Presenting issues
Anger, Insomnia, Nervousness, Lack of appetite, Grumpiness, Fear

5 May 2005
  • Has had PTSD since returning from active military service in 1973.
  • Deeper and longer sleep from use of the recording.
  • Feeling more calm since using the recording.
12 May 2005
  • Energy levels are higher.
  • Much deeper sleep.
  • Can go straight back to sleep after waking at night.
  • Feeling calmer and happier.
  • Not feeling so grumpy all the time.
19 May 2005
  • Only one angry outburst during the preceding week, where he used to have four or five a day.
  • Sleep still improved.
  • Blood markers have dropped, according to the oncologist.
  • Energy levels still up and appetite increasing.
  • Swallowing much easier and food goes straight down now.
31 May 2005
  • Still feeling great.
  • Energy levels still up.
  • Sleeping still fine.
  • One day of metallic taste in the mouth after drinking water.
  • One day of nausea after eating.
7 June 2005
  • Metallic taste now only occasional and seventy five to eighty per cent reduced.
  • Good appetite.
  • Deep sleeps.
  • Energy levels still up.
  • A little concerned about the oncologist check-up on 8 June.
9 June 2005
  • Feeling over the moon.
  • Feeling better than he has felt in years.
  • The oncologist check-up on 8 June has given the all clear.
Final assessment, 9 June 2005
This has helped me tremendously, and not only to beat the cancer. It has helped with my sleep, my moods, my anger, my PTSD, my appetite, and my general outlook on life. I can't say how helpful exactly but if I had to put a figure on it I would say at least fifty per cent.
08

50 year old female

Diagnosis
Breast cancer, December 2003, with secondaries in the ovaries

Medical care
Left breast mastectomy and hysterectomy, radiation therapy and chemotherapy. Presently diagnosed with lymphoedema. Medications Tamoxifen and Efexor.

Presenting issues
Hot flushes, Night sweats, Itchy dry skin, Leg cramps, Aches in joints and bones, Weight gain, Disturbed sleep, Memory problems, Persistent cough

5 May 2005
  • The recording sends her into a deep sleep.
  • Pain in arms and shoulders from lymphoedema.
  • Brain fog feels more cleared up.
10 May 2005
  • Arm and shoulder pain has lessened quite a bit.
  • Feeling more energetic.
  • Sleeping better.
  • Feeling terrific.
17 May 2005
  • Much happier and stays that way longer.
  • Much better and deeper sleep every night.
  • Lymphoedema much less painful in arm and shoulders.
  • Persistent cough has settled after eighteen months.
31 May 2005
  • Previous cough completely gone.
  • Much clearer thinking.
  • Some pain in arms and shoulders, from trimming hedges and cutting firewood with a chainsaw.
  • Much more energy.
  • Feeling much happier.
  • Lost a kilogram in weight.
  • Others noticing improvements in her appearance and moods.
  • States she wants to discontinue Efexor. Advised only with her doctor's permission.
7 June 2005
  • Her doctor is very happy with her progress but wants her to remain on Efexor for another six months.
  • Has never felt this emotionally balanced in her life.
  • Pain has been non-existent since the last visit.
  • Still sleeping deeply and soundly.
  • Lymphoedema pain much less, and swelling goes down much faster after housework.
  • Cough still gone.
14 June 2005
  • All aches gone from arms and shoulders.
  • Minimal swelling in arms and shoulders.
  • Sleeping so well she slept in a couple of times, to her own surprise.
  • Energy levels have remained up.
Final assessment, 14 June 2005
I feel a lot more contented with my lot in life now, I listen to my body more and always have a better frame of mind. My cough has gone, my cramps and itching have gone, I am doing a lot more exercise with a lot less pain and fatigue. I feel like I have my life back and that I am back on track.
09

76 year old male

Diagnosis
Stomach cancer, December 2003

Medical care
Six months of regular chemotherapy and no other medications. Other non-medical treatment was vitamin B17 taken orally.

Presenting issues
Depression, Lack of energy, Lack of motivation, Problems swallowing

3 May 2005
  • Sleeping better from use of the recording.
  • Still feeling sad.
  • No physical energy.
  • Problems swallowing.
10 May 2005
  • Still sleeping better.
  • Still has trouble swallowing, and will now cease taking B17 of his own accord.
  • Energy still low.
  • Mood feels a little better.
24 May 2005
  • Feeling much better now.
  • Still sleeping well.
  • Energy feels as though it is returning, and he has taken some walks.
  • Walked three kilometres on the previous Monday.
  • Swallowing has gone back to normal.
31 May 2005
  • Feeling much happier.
  • His partner has noticed a big improvement in his moods.
  • Energy fluctuating up and down.
  • Still not exercising as much as he would like.
7 June 2005
  • Feeling about fifty per cent better overall.
  • Swallowing problem seems gone now.
  • Sleeping deeply.
  • Elimination systems working fine now.
  • Feeling happier with himself.
16 June 2005
  • Still feeling better and continuing to improve.
  • Appetite is better.
  • Mood is better.
  • Easier to eat and swallow.
  • Still needs motivation to walk more.
  • Sleeping deeply.
  • Feeling generally less worried about things.
Final assessment, 16 June 2005
I feel much better. I feel the best I have felt since the news of my cancer. I can eat and swallow comfortably again and my depression feels gone. I think that this treatment has been very very good for me.

References

  1. Richardson MA, Straus SE. Complementary and alternative medicine: opportunities and challenges for cancer management and research. Semin Oncol 2002, 29, 531-545.
  2. Sommer HJ, Burgi M, Theiss R. Komplementarmedizin in der Krankenversicherung. Schweiz Med Wsch 1998, 128, 1-129.
  3. Di Gianni LM, Garber JE, Winer EP. Complementary and alternative medicine use among women with breast cancer. J Clin Oncol 2002, 20, 34s-38s.
  4. CAM-CANCER, European Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer.
  5. Marcus J, Elkins G, Mott F. The integration of hypnosis into a model of palliative care. Integr Cancer Ther. 2003 Dec;2(4):365-70.
  6. Astin JA, Shapiro SL, Eisenberg DM, Forys KL. Mind-body medicine: state of the science, implications for practice. J Am Board Fam Pract. 2003 Mar-Apr;16(2):131-47.
  7. Iglesias A. Hypnosis and existential psychotherapy with end-stage terminally ill patients. Am J Clin Hypn. 2004 Jan;46(3):201-13.
  8. Stalpers LJ, da Costa HC, Merbis MA, Fortuin AA, Muller MJ, van Dam FS. Hypnotherapy in radiotherapy patients: a randomized trial. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2005 Feb 1;61(2):499-506.
  9. Taylor EE, Ingleton C. Hypnotherapy and cognitive-behaviour therapy in cancer care: the patients' view. Eur J Cancer Care (Engl). 2003 Jun;12(2):137-42.
  10. Winkelman J, Pies R. Current patterns and future directions in the treatment of insomnia. Ann Clin Psychiatry. 2005 Jan-Mar;17(1):31-40.
  11. Edinger JD, Means MK. Cognitive-behavioral therapy for primary insomnia. Clin Psychol Rev. 2005 Jun 9.
  12. Oi-Ling K, Man-Wah DT, Kam-Hung DN. Symptom distress as rated by advanced cancer patients, caregivers and physicians in the last week of life. Palliat Med. 2005 Apr;19(3):228-33.
  13. Tiller JWG. The management of insomnia: an update. Aust Prescr 2003;26:78-81.
  14. Sood A, Moynihan TJ. Cancer-related fatigue: an update. Curr Oncol Rep. 2005 Jul;7(4):277-82.
  15. Okamura M, Yamawaki S, Akechi T, Taniguchi K, Uchitomi Y. Psychiatric disorders following first breast cancer recurrence: prevalence, associated factors and relationship to quality of life. Jpn J Clin Oncol. 2005 Jun 16.
See the trainings About Rick Collingwood